Insight · Revenue System

Why a new CRM will not fix your forecast problem.

Most CRM projects do not fail because of the software. They fail because they answer a system problem with a tool.

Ronny Steinhagen · 4 minutes

The sales director of a mid-sized technology company told me in our first conversation: “Our problems will be solved quickly once we finally have a CRM worthy of the name.” He was right about the system – what he had was a hybrid of ERP and accounting, not a CRM. He was wrong about the conclusion.

Because the questions his managing director put to him every quarter had nothing to do with software: why does the forecast deviate by 30 per cent again and again? Why have deals been sitting in “negotiation” for four months? Why does nobody know which opportunities are actually reliable?

A new CRM that reproduces the old processes digitally is not progress. It is the old problem with a better interface.

A tool reflects what is – not what ought to be

A CRM is a mirror. It shows pipeline stages, win probabilities and activities exactly as the team enters them. If nobody has defined what a stage means, when a deal moves from “qualified” to “proposal” and who decides that, then the system produces exactly what it produced before: a list of hopes with percentages next to them.

I have seen companies roll out three CRM systems in eight years. Every time with the expectation that transparency would come from the software. Every time with the same result after twelve months.

What has to be settled before the tool

Before a CRM can deliver forecast quality, four questions need answers – and IT asks none of them:

The right order

The revenue system first: stages, criteria, accountability, rhythm. Then the tool that reflects and enforces that system. In this order a CRM is a lever. In the reverse order it is a cost item with a training requirement.

The sales director from the first paragraph did get a new CRM, by the way. But only after we had run the pipeline manually for four months – in a spreadsheet, with weekly reviews, with criteria that were argued over. By the time the system was rolled out there was nothing left to discuss. All it did was reflect what already worked.

Your forecast does not hold even though the CRM is in place? Then the cause is rarely in the system. A short conversation will establish where it actually lies.

Discuss an engagement